Therapist Testifies in Ontario Murder Trial of Two Women

A child and family therapist testified in the ongoing murder trial of Brandy Cooney and Becky Hamber that she never recommended they consistently puree food for the two boys under their care. The trial, which began in mid-September, is taking place in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice in Milton and revolves around the death of one of the boys, identified as L.L., who died on December 21, 2022, while in the couple’s care.

The therapists’ statements are central to the prosecution’s case, as the Crown alleges that the women abused and neglected L.L. and his brother, J.L.. During her testimony, Terra Bovingdon described her work with the boys in 2018 and 2019, emphasizing that her suggestions included serving smoothies to help the children cope with trauma, not pureed food on a regular basis.

Details of the Testimony

Bovingdon explained that her approach included helping families understand the brain’s responses to trauma and using techniques such as play and repetition. She noted that children with trauma often respond poorly to immediate consequences, such as being sent to their rooms, and recommended activities that are rhythmic, like biking or jumping on a trampoline, to soothe the boys.

During her testimony, Bovingdon clarified that she did not recommend treating the boys as toddlers on an ongoing basis. When questioned by Crown prosecutor Monica MacKenzie, she reiterated that while she acknowledged the boys might sometimes act younger than their age, her advice was to engage with them in short, age-appropriate activities.

In stark contrast, J.L. previously testified that he was confined to his room for more than 90 percent of the time and fed only pureed food. The defense has suggested that their actions were based on Bovingdon’s guidance, an assertion she directly refuted.

Events Leading to the Tragedy

The Crown has presented evidence alleging that L.L. was found unresponsive in a locked room, severely malnourished, and emaciated. Paramedics reported that he appeared to be the size of a six-year-old, despite being twelve at the time of his death. He died shortly after being taken to the hospital.

Defense attorneys argue that Cooney and Hamber were attempting to care for two children with significant behavioral needs, facing challenges in obtaining support from the Children’s Aid Society (CAS) and other service providers. Witnesses, including medical professionals and educators, have provided testimony regarding the boys’ treatment and the circumstances leading up to L.L.’s death.

In a chilling revelation, the trial witnessed recordings of the couple allegedly taunting J.L., alongside images depicting injuries on his feet. J.L. has also recounted being restrained and locked in rooms, raising serious concerns about the care he and his brother received.

Testimony from Chelsey Harding, a former child and youth worker, added another layer to the trial. Harding expressed her struggles in working with the couple and ultimately left her position, stating, “I did not work with parents like Becky and Brandy anymore.” She indicated that the couple’s unwillingness to collaborate made it difficult for her to provide effective support for the boys.

As the trial continues, it is expected to feature additional witnesses and evidence, with the next session scheduled for Monday. The outcome of this case may have significant implications for the ongoing discussions about child welfare and parental rights in Ontario.

Those affected by the content of this report are encouraged to seek mental health support through available resources in their province or territory.