Owners of Emily Carr’s Historic House Seek Rental Exemption

The owners of the lesser-known House of Allsorts, a historic building linked to artist Emily Carr in Victoria, British Columbia, are requesting an exemption from short-term rental regulations. This exemption is crucial for funding necessary upkeep and restoration of the property, which is over 112 years old and holds significant historical value.

Located in the heart of Victoria, the House of Allsorts is notable for being the only privately owned historic site in British Columbia. Carr resided there during her adulthood, naming it the House of Allsorts. The house still displays her artistic influence, particularly in the attic, where original paintings by Carr adorn the ceiling. While some artworks on the walls are reproductions, the ceiling features her genuine creations, providing a glimpse into the artist’s life and work.

Current owner Peter Willis, whose grandmother purchased the house in 1973, seeks to preserve the property, which has been designated as a historic site since shortly after the acquisition. Unlike the nearby Emily Carr House, which is owned and maintained by the province, the maintenance of the House of Allsorts falls solely on Willis. He expressed his belief that the province has a moral obligation to support the preservation of Carr’s legacy.

Willis proposes that securing a short-term rental exemption would significantly enhance his ability to fund restoration efforts, which are estimated to cost around $800,000. Currently, the house accommodates long-term tenants on the lower floor, while the second floor features two rental suites with minimum 90-day stays. However, as Willis does not reside in the property, he is prohibited from listing it on short-term rental platforms, which he sees as a missed opportunity for financial support.

“I think I can do it if I get a short-term rental exemption,” he stated, emphasizing the urgency of the situation. The request for exemption is currently being handled by the Attorney General’s legal services branch, which has not yet issued a response regarding the matter.

As discussions continue, the future of the House of Allsorts remains uncertain. The outcome of this request could play a critical role in ensuring the preservation of this significant piece of British Columbia’s artistic heritage.