Rare Waterfront Home on Wellesley Pond Hits the Market

A unique historic home that dates back to the pre-Confederation era has become available for sale on the shores of Wellesley Pond. This property, located at 44 David St. in Ontario, blends historic charm with modern living in a picturesque setting.

The residence features the original log cabin structure from 1860 and offers 2,031 square feet of living space, including three bedrooms and two bathrooms. Priced at $799,900, this listing marks the first time in decades that the home has been on the market, as the owner is relocating to be closer to family.

Historic Features and Modern Updates

Ken Cameron, a veteran broker with RE/MAX Solid Gold Realty, described the property as “probably the most unique home I’ve had the privilege of selling” during his 40 years in the business. The home has been well-maintained by the same owner since 1988, who undertook significant renovations, including a kitchen and loft addition in 2006.

The living room showcases exposed beams and log walls, creating an inviting atmosphere. A side door leads to a 25-foot covered porch, perfect for enjoying the outdoors. The dining area is spacious enough to accommodate large family gatherings, making it ideal for entertaining.

One of the standout features of this home is its connection to nature, with over 130 feet of shoreline on Wellesley Pond. This rare waterfront property offers a lifestyle that includes fishing and exploration right from the backyard. The main-floor primary bedroom, added in 1970, opens onto a private 14-by-10-foot deck, providing a serene spot to enjoy morning coffee while watching the sunrise.

The kitchen has been remodeled with custom cherry wood cabinetry by Cerwood and features a Heartland five-burner electric stove, making it a culinary enthusiast’s dream. A large island provides ample workspace, while a hideaway loft offers a clever spot for a home office or reading nook.

Family-Friendly Amenities

The main floor hosts a generously sized bathroom equipped with quality plumbing fixtures, including a standalone MAAX oval soaker tub and an oversized shower with glass door and seat. A laundry closet adds to the home’s convenience, catering to modern family needs.

The upper floor features two additional large bedrooms and a two-piece bathroom, with pine flooring adding warmth and character. The property includes two separate basements: the original low-ceiling space and a full-height area under the kitchen addition, suitable for a workshop or extra storage.

Cameron highlighted the practical benefits of this home, including connections to municipal water and sewer services, eliminating the need for a septic tank or well. The large lot also features a detached 19-by-25-foot workshop, ideal for hobbyists.

Determining a price for such a distinctive property posed a challenge for Cameron, who relied on his experience and intuition rather than comparative market analysis, as there are no direct benchmarks available. He noted, “I know you’d like to sort of refer back to previous sales, and it probably goes way, way back, so that doesn’t help anybody.”

With its blend of historic character, extensive renovations, and waterfront access, Cameron believes this home presents an exceptional opportunity for potential buyers. He confidently listed the property at $799,900, making it an appealing option for a young family seeking a unique residence in the scenic Waterloo Region.

According to GeoWarehouse, a centralized property information platform, the house last sold for $99,000 in October 1988, highlighting the significant appreciation in value over the decades.